Simple little boats: pool noodles
Nautical letters, Bouknecht Boutique Make the players name out of cork board with a small basketball on the bottom or college choice
Fiesta pirata, ¡consigue tu pack de pegatinas gratis!
Nautical Favor Bag by MadebyKrizia on Etsy
could pair this with the brown paper treasure map table cloth!
May use on my own diy sign Pirate Birthday Party Door Sign